2

We have the tags (x6) and (x65). Should the two be merged, with translation becoming a synonym to localization? The current 6 "translation questions" deal with topics very close to "localization", which would speak for a merge. A possible argument against could be the term "translation" being applied to content as well (as e.g. with "Google Translate").

Being unsure, I seek your opinions. Clearly, we have two options:

  • Yes: Merge the two and synonymize. Optionally update the tag wiki of "localization" to make it clear.
  • No: Translation should be applied to content. In this case:
    • re-tag questions closer related to "localization"
    • create a tag wiki for "translation" making clear what this tag is about

What do you think? Maybe I even missed a third option?

EDIT: I just noticed a third related tag: (x76)...

2

Sorry for short-circuiting your vote, but this seemed pretty clear-cut to me since most of the translation questions were in fact localization questions. I've merged and synonymized.

I think is alright to stay separate since it seems like a proper subset of localization, but I'm open to other options.

  • No need to be sorry (and thanks for your action!) -- I just took into consideration that others might be as confused as me. Good that someone (you) has a clear view on this :) I was tending to the same direction, or I wouldn't have asked. So what's left is me checking the tag wikis of the two remaining tags whether they might need some clearification. Will do so on this weekend (currently I'm a little in a rush). Thanks again! – Izzy Feb 22 '13 at 17:01
  • @Izzy No problem, thanks again for all your work on our tags lately! – Matthew Read Feb 22 '13 at 17:24
  • Also no problem :) – Izzy Feb 22 '13 at 18:52
2

Yes, we should merge the two: should be the merge target, translation should become its synonym.

0

No, the two should stay separate:

  • shall remain for the "technical issue" of having apps and their dialogs, hints, etc. using the local language, which will of course include "helping to translate an app" (How can I make Android to always use my language, including all its apps? being a possible example question). The tag wiki might need to be updated to make this clear.
  • should be used for content related questions/issues, such as e.g. problems with translation apps (Google Translate & Co) as well as questions like How can I automatically translate web pages in the stock browser?
    • questions tagged 'translation' but rather referring to different topics should be re-tagged
    • a tag wiki should be created for the translation tag to make its use clear

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .