0

I just found a question tagged bot, (x2) and (x198). Does that really make sense? One could argue the former is for the service, while the latter is for the app. Wrong: Both questions tagged 'google-mail' are about the app (GMail app setup, install google apps).

Thinking about it: All our google apps tags tart with google-* (e.g. google-play-[store|music|books|movies], or google-[maps|talk|voice|calendar|plus|...]. So a tag like google-mail makes absolutely sense to me, and would count as "consolidation". Hence my suggestion:

Merge the two making google-mail the master and gmail a synonym to it. There's not a lot of tag wiki for either of them (just an excerpt on gmail which could easily be cut'n'paste (for Germans: Guttenberg-Schavant ;)).

  • TBH, I would have thought the other way would make more sense. Do people actually refer to it as "Google Mail" anymore? The official branding is simply "Gmail", whereas the other ones are all officially "Google [whatever]" (Maps, Play, etc) so their tags follow the actual names. /cc @Flow – eldarerathis Mar 19 '13 at 14:43
  • 1
    People can still use the gmail tag. It will just be rewritten to google-mail. Most people I know refer to it as 'Google Mail'. But that may depends on where you live. gmail was a trademark in germany, so google couldn't use it for years. – Flow Mar 19 '13 at 17:36
  • 1
    @Flow: They can still "use" it, sure, but the tag will not display as "gmail". I guess that simply seems counterintuitive to me since the name of the app (and web service) is "Gmail". – eldarerathis Mar 19 '13 at 18:23
  • If you want to match the format of the existing tags, google-maps, google-calendar, etc. then shouldn't be google-gmail?! (Although I wouldn't recommend that.) We had the same issue in the UK... it was officially known as Googlemail for a long time, and I still encounter these email addresses. However, we still used the term gmail in common usage. I'm torn, but I think gmail is a special case. – MrWhite Mar 19 '13 at 23:41
  • The name of the product is Gmail. – ale Mar 20 '13 at 0:38
3

Good catch. By popular demand now points to .

  • The official name for the app is "Gmail". – ale Mar 19 '13 at 23:48

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .