2

Should I ask for Android app recommendation on main site or on Software Recommendations?

5

No, app recommendations are off-topic for us, just because they don't work very well with the SE format, which favours questions with an objectively correct answer. That said, if you have a specific problem to solve, and the answer might be one of:

  • App X can solve your problem
  • You need to install a custom ROM to do that
  • There isn't an app, but if you do A in app X, and then B in app Y, then it'll solve your problem

and you'd be happy with any of those answers, then your question isn't an app recommendation: it's a problem-solving question. In that case, it's fine (unless it's off-topic for a different reason, such as you're trying to use an iPhone, not Android).

Software Recommendations has its own guidance, What topics can I ask about here?, explaining what makes a question suitable for that site.

Good software recommendation requests have two components:

  • A purpose — a task to accomplish, a user story
  • Some objective requirements — a minimum set of features

If your question has those, and you're definitely looking for an app, then your question is probably a better fit for that site.

If you don't have a purpose or objective requirements - for example, your question is "Which music player should I use?" - then your question probably isn't a good fit for any SE site, because of the aforementioned limitations of the format. In that case, you should probably ask on a discussion forum or on Reddit, where questions can be completely subjective and have many answers.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .